The world’s largest stablecoin faces a fresh wave of scrutiny today after a major financial watchdog sounded the alarm. S&P Global Ratings downgraded Tether from constrained to weak in its latest assessment. The agency cites growing risks tied to the massive amount of Bitcoin sitting in Tether reserves. This move triggered a fierce response from Tether leadership and reignited the debate over stablecoin safety.
Rating Drop Sparks Stability Fears
S&P Global Ratings has officially lowered its safety score for USDT. The firm shifted the stablecoin from a constrained rating to a weak one. This change reflects deep concerns about how the company backs its digital dollar. Analysts believe the asset mix is becoming too risky for a currency meant to stay stable.
The primary issue lies in the lack of a full official audit. Tether relies on attestations rather than complete audits to show its money. S&P noted this lack of transparency as a major red flag for investors. They warned that without a clear view inside, trust remains fragile.
Another major worry is the volatility of the assets backing the coin. If the assets holding up the dollar value crash, the peg could break. S&P analysts warned that a sharp market downturn could leave the stablecoin undercollateralized. This means there might not be enough money to pay everyone back at once.
Key Concerns Raised by S&P:
- Lack of a full, independent financial audit.
- Heavy exposure to volatile assets like Bitcoin.
- Risks involving corporate bonds and secured loans.
- Potential inability to handle a massive bank run.
-
tether usdt coin balancing on bitcoin chart background
Bitcoin Bet Grows to Billions
The sheer volume of Bitcoin held by Tether has become a focal point of the controversy. The company’s latest transparency reports reveal it holds over 87,000 BTC. This is a massive stash that makes it one of the largest Bitcoin holders on the planet.
The value of this Bitcoin holding fluctuates wildly with the market. At current prices, these holdings represent roughly 5.4% of the platform’s total reserves. This is a significant jump from the 3.6% reported in previous quarters.
Critics argue this strategy defeats the purpose of a stablecoin. A stablecoin is supposed to be boring and safe. Bitcoin is famous for being exciting and volatile. S&P analysts Rebecca Mun and Mohamed Damak highlighted this contradiction in their report.
“USDT could become undercollateralized if there is a large decline in the Bitcoin price. This would impinge on the stablecoin’s ability to hold its peg with the dollar.”
This exposure creates a direct link between crypto prices and USDT stability. If Bitcoin crashes by 50% tomorrow, billions of dollars in backing value vanish instantly. This scenario is what keeps traditional risk assessors up at night.
Tether Boss Slams Old Finance Models
Tether CEO Paolo Ardoino did not take the downgrade quietly. He took to social media platform X to fire back at the rating agency. His response was defiant and highlighted the divide between crypto and traditional banking.
Ardoino stated that he wears their “loathing with pride.” He argues that traditional finance models are broken and outdated. He pointed out that these same agencies gave high ratings to banks that later collapsed.
Tether’s Defense Strategy:
| Criticism | Tether Response |
|---|---|
| Risky Assets | We hold huge excess reserves to cover volatility. |
| Lack of Audit | We provide quarterly attestations and have massive liquidity. |
| Downgrade | Traditional ratings fail to understand modern finance. |
The CEO emphasized that Tether is overcapitalized. He claims the company does not hold “toxic reserves” like traditional banks often do. He believes the immense profits Tether generates act as a safety cushion that S&P ignores.
Ardoino sees the downgrade as a badge of honor. He believes it proves Tether is doing something different than the failing legacy system. He urged the world to look at the actual track record of stability rather than theoretical scores.
Treasury Bills vs Volatile Assets
Despite the Bitcoin controversy, Tether still holds the majority of its money in safe assets. The company claims to be the 17th largest holder of U.S. Treasury bills in the world. This places them ahead of many sovereign nations in terms of U.S. debt ownership.
These Treasury bills provide a solid floor for the stablecoin. They are considered one of the safest investments on earth. Tether uses the interest from these bills to generate massive quarterly profits.
However, the mix of assets remains the sticking point. Alongside Treasuries and Bitcoin, the company also holds gold and secured loans. The secured loans make up about 8% of the collateral.
S&P warns that these loans add another layer of hidden risk. If the borrowers default during a crisis, that money is gone. The combination of loans, gold, and Bitcoin creates a complex risk profile.
Investors are now left to weigh the two sides. On one side is a profitable giant with billions in government bonds. On the other is a “weak” rated entity betting big on volatile crypto. The market must decide which narrative to trust as the ecosystem evolves.
Current Reserve Breakdown Estimates:
- U.S. Treasuries: The vast majority (Safety layer).
- Bitcoin: approx. 5.4% (Growth/Risk layer).
- Secured Loans: approx. 8% (Liquidity layer).
- Gold & Cash: Remaining balance.
The debate ultimately comes down to philosophy. S&P applies strict banking standards to a crypto company. Tether argues those standards no longer apply in a digital economy.
Conclusion
The downgrade by S&P Global Ratings serves as a stark warning to the crypto industry. It highlights the ongoing tension between traditional risk management and the aggressive strategies of stablecoin issuers. While Tether boasts massive profits and Treasury holdings, its increasing bet on Bitcoin has officially labeled it as “weak” in the eyes of institutional assessors. Investors must now decide if they trust Paolo Ardoino’s vision of a new financial system or S&P’s century of risk analysis experience.
What do you think about Tether’s Bitcoin strategy? Is it a genius move or a ticking time bomb? Share your thoughts in the comments below or tweet your opinion using #TetherDowngrade.
